commit 791ab635f6558c2ec67570265ef9cffb457f9af3 Author: SoniEx2 Date: Fri Sep 14 02:42:25 2018 -0300 Initial commit. Add all known versions of newclog. Version 0 is the latest. Version -1 is the second latest. Version -2 is the third latest. Versions -3 and back, I didn't manage to recover. diff --git a/v-1 b/v-1 new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3c3000f --- /dev/null +++ b/v-1 @@ -0,0 +1,94 @@ +CAP prefix/clog +=============== + +Copyright (c) Soni L. \ + +This capability provides a mechanism for identifying and conveying a cryptographically secured list of messages to IRC clients. + +This specification also suggests a mechanism by which IRC clients can sync logs, using the information provided by this capability. + +Cap syntax +---------- + +The capability shall be specified as + + prefix/clog=hash_type,hash_type/tag,tag,tag + +Example: + + prefix/clog=sha1,sha256/server-time + +`server-time` is always implicitly specified, and should be omitted. + +The `HASH` S2C command +---------------------- + +The `HASH` command shall be sent for hashes associated with a channel. + +Each hash must be a cryptographic hash. Non-cryptographic hashes must be ignored. Broken hash algorithms should be avoided. MD5 is explicitly disallowed and must not be used. + +The counter must be able to store numbers in the `0..2^62-1` range. + +These hashes specify the current "heads" of the clog. This is similar to git heads, if you're familiar with them. + +Syntax: + + HASH #channel :hash_type=counter/hash,type=counter/hash,... + +Example: + + >>> JOIN #channel + <<< JOIN #channel + <<< NAMES etc + <<< HASH #channel :sha1=20,something_long + <<< HASH #channel :sha1=60,something_else sha256=70,another + +Optionally, the server may include a server name with the HASH command: + + <<< :server1.example.com HASH #channel :etc + <<< :server2.example.com HASH #channel :other + +The `hash` message tag +---------------------- + +The `hash` mesaage tag shall be sent with every `PRIVMSG`, `TOPIC` and `NOTICE`. + +Syntax: + + hash=type=counter/short_hash,type=counter/short_hash,... + +The use of `short_hash` lowers bandwidth requirements. Consult your cryptography expert for best practices on using cryptography. + +These hashes specify the previous "head(s)" of the clog. "Merges" are just messages with hashes from different sources. + +Example: + + TODO + +Security Considerations +----------------------- + +Clogs are meant for channels that want public logging. An example is the Rust IRC channel. As such, anything in a clog should be assumed public. + +It's possible to recover deleted clogs by setting up a separate IRC network and sending the right hashes on the right channel. However, you'd still need to know the hashes. +Thus, this isn't a vulnerability, because if you had the hashes, you could just request the logs directly, without going through the process of setting up an IRC network. + +The network could be made to sign all hashes, but you'd need to share the signing key across all servers for it to work correctly. This still doesn't prevent someone +from getting access to an intercepted, correctly-signed hash, and by sharing the signing key you increase the attack surface. + +[FIXME there may be more] + +The `SYNC` CTCP (informative) +----------------------------- + +*This section is informative.* + +The `SYNC` CTCP is a hypothetical CTCP for syncing logs. + +Syntax: + + SYNC <...> -[nospam+checksum] + +This is a highly flexible command supporting ipv4, ipv6, hostname, tor, i2p and tox ID. + +Messages sent over non-tox channels must be encrypted with the tox-compatible public key. diff --git a/v-2 b/v-2 new file mode 100644 index 0000000..729f2bd --- /dev/null +++ b/v-2 @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +CAP prefix/clog +=============== + +Copyright (c) Soni L. \ + +This capability provides a mechanism for identifying and conveying a cryptographically secured list of messages to IRC clients. + +This specification also suggests a mechanism by which IRC clients can sync logs, using the information provided by this capability. + +Cap syntax +---------- + +The capability shall be specified as + + prefix/clog=hash_type,hash_type/tag,tag,tag + +Example: + + prefix/clog=sha1,sha256/server-time + +`server-time` is always implicitly specified, and should be omitted. + +The `HASH` S2C command +---------------------- + +The `HASH` command shall be sent for hashes associated with a channel. + +Each hash must be a cryptographic hash. Non-cryptographic hashes must be ignored. Broken hash algorithms should be avoided. MD5 is explicitly disallowed and must not be used. + +The counter must be able to store numbers in the `0..2^62-1` range. + +Syntax: + + HASH #channel :hash_type=counter/hash,type=counter/hash,... + +Example: + + >>> JOIN #channel + <<< JOIN #channel + <<< NAMES etc + <<< HASH #channel :sha1=20,something_long + <<< HASH #channel :sha1=60,something_else sha256=70,another + +Optionally, the server may include a server name with the HASH command: + + <<< :server1.example.com HASH #channel :etc + <<< :server2.example.com HASH #channel :other + +The `hash` message tag +---------------------- + +The `hash` mesaage tag shall be sent with every `PRIVMSG`, `TOPIC` and `NOTICE`. + +Syntax: + + hash=type=counter/short_hash,type=counter/short_hash,... + +The use of `short_hash` lowers bandwidth requirements. Consult your cryptography expert for best practices on using cryptography. + +Example: + + TODO + +The `SYNC` CTCP (informative) +----------------------------- + +*This section is informative.* + +The `SYNC` CTCP is a hypothetical CTCP for syncing logs. + +Syntax: + + SYNC <...> -[nospam+checksum] + +This is a highly flexible command supporting ipv4, ipv6, hostname, tor, i2p and tox ID. + +Messages sent over non-tox channels must be encrypted with the tox-compatible public key. diff --git a/v0 b/v0 new file mode 100644 index 0000000..78f02db --- /dev/null +++ b/v0 @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +CAP prefix/clog +=============== + +Copyright (c) Soni L. \ + +This capability provides a mechanism for identifying and conveying a cryptographically secured list of messages to IRC clients. + +This specification also suggests a mechanism by which IRC clients can sync logs, using the information provided by this capability. + +Cap syntax +---------- + +The capability shall be specified as + + prefix/clog=hash_type,hash_type/tag,tag,tag + +Example: + + prefix/clog=sha1,sha256/server-time,prefix/hash + +`server-time` and `prefix/hash` are always implicitly specified, and should be omitted. + +The `HASH` S2C command +---------------------- + +The `HASH` command shall be sent for hashes associated with a channel. + +Each hash must be a cryptographic hash. Non-cryptographic hashes must be ignored. Broken hash algorithms should be avoided. MD5 is explicitly disallowed and must not be used. + +The counter must be able to store numbers in the `0..2^62-1` range. + +These hashes specify the current "heads" of the clog. This is similar to git heads, if you're familiar with them. + +Syntax: + + HASH #channel :hash_type=counter/hash,type=counter/hash,... + +Example: + + >>> JOIN #channel + <<< JOIN #channel + <<< NAMES etc + <<< HASH #channel :sha1=20,something_long + <<< HASH #channel :sha1=60,something_else sha256=70,another + +Optionally, the server may include a server name with the HASH command: + + <<< :server1.example.com HASH #channel :etc + <<< :server2.example.com HASH #channel :other + +The `hash` message tag +---------------------- + +The `hash` mesaage tag shall be sent with every `PRIVMSG`, `TOPIC` and `NOTICE`. + +Syntax: + + prefix/hash=type=counter/short_hash,type=counter/short_hash,... + +The use of `short_hash` lowers bandwidth requirements. Consult your cryptography expert for best practices on using cryptography. + +These hashes specify the previous "head(s)" of the clog. "Merges" are just messages with hashes from different sources. + +The hash encompasses the message tags specified by the capability (e.g. `server-time` and `hash`), sorted according to UTF-8 byte order, and the contents of the IRC message, as seen in the following format: + + @prefix/hash=...;server-time=... :nick!user@host PRIVMSG #channel :message + +(This line is what gets hashed) + +Examples: + + TODO + +Security Considerations +----------------------- + +Clogs are meant for channels that want public logging. An example is the Rust IRC channel. As such, anything in a clog should be assumed public. + +It's possible to recover deleted clogs by setting up a separate IRC network and sending the right hashes on the right channel. However, you'd still need to know the hashes. +Thus, this isn't a vulnerability, because if you had the hashes, you could just request the logs directly, without going through the process of setting up an IRC network. + +The network could be made to sign all hashes, but you'd need to share the signing key across all servers for it to work correctly. This still doesn't prevent someone +from getting access to an intercepted, correctly-signed hash, and by sharing the signing key you increase the attack surface. + +The server can and should be able to "undo" hashes. This is useful if, for example, someone posts child pornography - you likely don't want that permanently recorded in a channel's history. + +[FIXME there may be more] + +The `SYNC` CTCP (informative) +----------------------------- + +*This section is informative.* + +The `SYNC` CTCP is a hypothetical CTCP for syncing logs. + +Syntax: + + SYNC <...> -[nospam+checksum] + +This is a highly flexible command supporting ipv4, ipv6, hostname, tor, i2p and tox ID. + +Messages sent over non-tox channels must be encrypted with the tox-compatible public key.